Two more finishing coats of paint (THREE TOTAL, UGH!) and I closed the shutters to see the green surrounded by the parchment. One side of the house will have all the shutters closed because I'm closing up those windows to get the interior wall space.
I like it a lot! I am so glad I asked about this. No other color but gray was even on my radar. I would never have thought to do this on my own. Thank you!